D7, F9, G5

~MM

__________________
Blah, blah, blah werewolf. Smackity-smack not a werewolf. Suspicious of this fruit loop.
My vote this round will be for Player X.

C1, F1, H4, A4

B6

Did I get a bingo?

__________________
****Attention****

quote:

---

Originally posted by coasterdude84:

MM and WCFmo, those are all misses, however, I do have to admit a mistake I made on 12/30: @SnapShot, G3 was a hit.

---

Ugh, really? That totally screws my board I would have sank that long ago, instead of fishing for a ship these last few rounds

@SnapShot: Why did you not tell coaster about this error?

Now WCFmo gets some shots at him, based on this mistake?

~MM

__________________
Blah, blah, blah werewolf. Smackity-smack not a werewolf. Suspicious of this fruit loop.
My vote this round will be for Player X.

quote:

---

Originally posted by MeddlingMage:
Ugh, really? That totally screws my board I would have sank that long ago, instead of fishing for a ship these last few rounds

@SnapShot: Why did you not tell coaster about this error?

Now WCFmo gets some shots at him, based on this mistake?

~MM

---

To be honest, the game needs some major adjustment. It seems like the poster who catches the results right after the hit/miss announcement will have a huge advantage over others, and this is kind of a bummer for others who are at work/school/ or at an unfavorable time zone.

__________________
****Attention****

quote:

---

Originally posted by Kyosukee:
If we did it as a PM based thing with multiple sinks on the same shot being ascribed to a coin flip, would that improve the game a bit? Leave the chat in the thread for "i think you hit me's" and for alliance talk and "he's gonna backstab you bro" talk as well?

---

There simply shouldn't be a time stamp on when the shots are registered, and the person who landed the most shots should get the sink. Right now, it's kinda silly when someone landed 3-4 shots on a ship, then some guy comes in and steals the kill because he happens to be online while the GM is updating.

__________________
****Attention****

quote:

---

Originally posted by coasterdude84:
So what do you guys want to do here? Do we want to can this and restart it under different rules?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by WCFmo:
I think we need to finish the game out.

---

[14:49] <juni> u might wanna throw some suggestion out there so that the game can continue

Suggestion 1: Game continues. Changes come next game, you cannot unwind the fabric of time.

Suggestion 2: All shots occur simultaneously and one random person is given the kill.

quote:

---

Originally posted by WCFmo:
[14:49] <juni> u might wanna throw some suggestion out there so that the game can continue

Suggestion 1: Game continues. Changes come next game, you cannot unwind the fabric of time.

Suggestion 2: All shots occur simultaneously and one random person is given the kill.

Suggestion 3: If ship is sunk then you determine who had most shots on it and if that person shot it the turn it was sank.

---

I am fine with #1 & #3. Not a fan of random, so #2 is a no for me.

__________________
****Attention****

I'm assuming 3 requires the ship to have been shot by the most damaging person the same round as the other guy? For example A can't claim a kill for X's 5 person ship that he damaged by 3 when B shoots for the kill next round and A shoots elsewhere?

quote:

---

Originally posted by coasterdude84:
Ok, we'll finish this one out, and then hammer out the details before the next game. I like #3 as well, but we do have an issue where we'll have to make a decision about evenly split ships, such as a 1-and-1 on the Destroyer.

Obviously, WCFmo sinks SnapShots last ship (@G2 and G4 by the way), but I'll split it with MeddlingMage, so they'll each get 1/2 a kill. Fair? And @WCFmo, B6 is a miss. Next round is open.

---

Whoever find the ship (ie Destroyer) and doesn't sink it, should get credit for the kill. By doing this, no other player, would want to send missles at a ship, that they may not get credit for sinking.

What will we do if a player has 1 ship left (like Snap did this game) and a player has 4 shots. Uses 1 shot to kill the last ship, then looks around and sees that he could sink another ship, of another player, but won't get credit for the kill?
Does that question make sense?

I'm almost thinking that the game limits players (maybe like 8 per game) for starters, and then maybe assign every player a "bounty". Like PM a player and say 'Your Archenemy this round is Player X'.

Most likely everyone would be after everyone else (chances to players draw to battle each other are rare), and then, once their bounty player is killed, can then feel free to 'snipe' other boats and such.

Just my thoughts.

~MM

__________________
Blah, blah, blah werewolf. Smackity-smack not a werewolf. Suspicious of this fruit loop.
My vote this round will be for Player X.

quote:

---

Originally posted by MeddlingMage:
Whoever find the ship (ie Destroyer) and doesn't sink it, should get credit for the kill. By doing this, no other player, would want to send missles at a ship, that they may not get credit for sinking.

What will we do if a player has 1 ship left (like Snap did this game) and a player has 4 shots. Uses 1 shot to kill the last ship, then looks around and sees that he could sink another ship, of another player, but won't get credit for the kill?
Does that question make sense?

I'm almost thinking that the game limits players (maybe like 8 per game) for starters, and then maybe assign every player a "bounty". Like PM a player and say 'Your Archenemy this round is Player X'.

Most likely everyone would be after everyone else (chances to players draw to battle each other are rare), and then, once their bounty player is killed, can then feel free to 'snipe' other boats and such.

Just my thoughts.

~MM

---

Thoughts on my thoughts?

~MM

__________________
Blah, blah, blah werewolf. Smackity-smack not a werewolf. Suspicious of this fruit loop.
My vote this round will be for Player X.

D9, F7, I3, I4

MM, why don't we wait till next game to decide how to implement changes?

quote:

---

Originally posted by MeddlingMage:
Whoever find the ship (ie Destroyer) and doesn't sink it, should get credit for the kill. By doing this, no other player, would want to send missiles at a ship, that they may not get credit for sinking.

What will we do if a player has 1 ship left (like Snap did this game) and a player has 4 shots. Uses 1 shot to kill the last ship, then looks around and sees that he could sink another ship, of another player, but won't get credit for the kill?
Does that question make sense?

I'm almost thinking that the game limits players (maybe like 8 per game) for starters, and then maybe assign every player a "bounty". Like PM a player and say 'Your Archenemy this round is Player X'.

Most likely everyone would be after everyone else (chances to players draw to battle each other are rare), and then, once their bounty player is killed, can then feel free to 'snipe' other boats and such.

Just my thoughts.

~MM

---

I think what we need to remember is that the real objective of the game is survival. Number of sinks/kills is just a means of breaking a potential tie. By keeping track of it, I meant to motivate people to participate, as opposed to sitting, letting everyone else beat each other up, and then move in for the kill. I didn't want a scenario where Player A kills everyone but Player B, who's mostly just sat and watched quietly, and then B kills a weakened A, making B the easy winner. Player A should still be awarded something I thought, but maybe that was just a bad decision on my part. More likely, Players A, C, and D would realize B is the front-runner and turn their collective guns on him.

__________________
****Attention****

B1

__________________
****Attention****