posted December 24, 2003 09:06 PM            

Phage hits straight, says "Your opponent loses."

I'm positive that Phage's ability is overruled by Platinum Angel's, as your opponent would win via Phage and you would lose, neither of which are permitted by it's ability.

posted December 25, 2003 10:14 AM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by Penguin Warlord:
Platinum Angel states "You cannot lose the game, your opponent cannot win the game."

Phage hits straight, says "Your opponent loses."

I'm positive that Phage's ability is overruled by Platinum Angel's, as your opponent would win via Phage and you would lose, neither of which are permitted by it's ability.

---

posted December 25, 2003 11:53 AM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by teroknorevents:
Correct. Platinum Angel replaces Phage's "You lose the game" ability with nothing. You do not lose, your opponent does not win, and the game continues.

---

103.2. When one effect says something can happen and another says it can't, the "can't" effect wins.

posted December 25, 2003 12:29 PM            

2. If planar void is in play, and an artifact goes to the graveyard, does the artifact remain in the yard long enough to be returned by a goblin welder?

posted December 25, 2003 12:34 PM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by Paul_Graham:
1. If a tangle wire's ability is on the stack, and the tangle wire leaves play before the ability resolves, how many permanants must be tapped (one for each fade counter that was on it, or none as when the ability resolves it sees no fade counters)?

2. If planar void is in play, and an artifact goes to the graveyard, does the artifact remain in the yard long enough to be returned by a goblin welder?

Thanks

---

1.) The game looks back to see how many counters it had right before it left play.

2.) Text on void:

Planar Void
Color: Black
Type: Enchantment
Cost: B
Sets: US(U)
Text(US): Whenever a card is put into a graveyard, remove that card from the game.

Because it starts with "Whenever" that indicates it's a triggered ability, which mean's it uses the stack, which means you have a chance to Weld the card into play.

__________________
Veteran of the 6:22 and 8:50 threads.

Good work men.

12/4-12/5 R.I.P

posted December 26, 2003 01:11 PM            

Q1:If i pay the entwine cost do i get to draw my 5 cards first then put the demon into play?

Q2:If i have promise of power and chainer's edict imprinted on spellweaver's helix and play an edict do i get to draw 5 cards and put the demon into play or just one or the other?

posted December 26, 2003 04:57 PM            

i believe you can pay the entwine to get both effects for pop
but otherwise choose one

if you entwine u draw 5 then put the demon into play (iirc it's in the mirrodin faq)

flashback = playing the spell

posted December 28, 2003 11:46 AM            

Onslaught
Legions
Scourge

posted December 28, 2003 05:33 PM            

If you activate the charbelcher and reveal your whole library without hitting a land, does it still do damage equal to the number of cards you revealed when you hit the end of your library?

and.....(pretty sure i know the answer to this one, just want to be sure)

If you reveal cards and hit a dual land with red(counts as a mountain) does it double the damage?

__________________
CARNOPHAGE COLLECTION COUNT!
English:22
Spanish:5
Japan:3
Chinese:5
Korean:10
Signed by artist:3
Foil:5

posted December 29, 2003 11:45 PM            

First off,

The stack resolves one item at a time correct? And you can respond to each resolution?

If someone plays, say a meddling mage, can i brainstorm in response... pull a counterspell with that brain storm then counter the mage?

I assume so, but i dont want to be an idiot in person, better off here

This is a less dumb question!

If I imprint AK (Accumulated Knowledge) on a Isochron..... and then later in the game I cunning wish

on resolution can I pick the AK removed by the isochron? Burningwish FAQ seems to say so...

And if i do, is it still imprinted on the isochron? Ie does 2 and tap still give me the AK ability?

And LASTLY, does the end result of all this possibly mean that you can draw 5 from AK's effect?

posted December 29, 2003 11:55 PM            

Wishes can fetch there respective cards from the "removed from the game" zone. This is the same place every card removed from the games goes regardless of how it was removed from the game.

If you remove the card imprinted on an artifact the artifact can no longer find the card and is usless in that sence. (I am not positive on this on and am to lazy to look it up; some one else please confirm)

If Accumulated Knowledge was imprinted on Scepter and there were 4 in the graveyard then of course you would draw 5 cards.

posted December 30, 2003 05:12 PM            

__________________
DCI L-1 Judge

posted December 30, 2003 06:23 PM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by axn:
the answer to that is in the mirrodin FAQ
in short, yes, the card that is imprinted may not be wished for unless you want to lose the imprint

you respond to items being put on the stack
once the top object resolves, active player has priority
you have no chance to respond unless he or she decides to pass

---

posted December 30, 2003 11:07 PM            

Meaning if you only had 9 cards in your library and he had 5, you'd both lose from the 10 point prosperity and the game will be a draw.

__________________
DCI L-1 Judge